Relative judgement is the steady half
People are consistent at ratios and unreliable at absolutes. Shown two lines, almost anyone can say which is longer and roughly by how much; asked to draw a line of exactly nine centimetres, the same group scatters widely. A comparison puzzle leans entirely on the first skill and never tests the second. Nothing in a round asks you to name a figure, which is why it works on objects you have never held.